Concepts
The racial notion over time
The racial notion has evolved over time and has taken on different meanings depending on the times and cultures, while keeping certain constants as the notion of hereditary traits. Although the concept of race as we know it today has taken shape over the centuries, traces of this concept can be found in ancient times and in the Middle Ages. This page aims to examine the evidence of the existence of the notion of race throughout history and explore how it has evolved.
Antiquity
In ancient times, the notion of race existed mainly in the form of ethnic and cultural distinctions. Ancient peoples often classified others according to their geographical origin and cultural traits rather than their physical characteristics, because they were associated with them and were general. - Ancient Greeks used the term "ethnos" to refer to groups of people who share a common origin and customs (Herodotus, Histories, 5th century BC). They classified non-Greek peoples, such as the Persians and Egyptians, as "barbars" because of their cultural differences, especially linguistic differences.
- The Romans, for their part, considered the different tribes and peoples they met as "gents" or "nations" (Tacite, Germania, 1st century AD). In Latin "natio" or "nationes" means a group of people who share a common origin or ancestry. The Latin term "natio" is itself derived from the verb "nasci", which means "nature". Thus, the concept of nation is closely linked to the idea of a common origin and a shared relationship among the members of a group. The Latin word "gentes" means a group of families sharing a common name and ancestry. The "gents" were therefore social and political groups based on shared family identity and affiliation.
Middle Ages
In the Middle Ages, the notion of race took the form of ethnic, national and religious distinctions. The classification of peoples was based on criteria such as religion, language and membership of a nation or kingdom. - Medieval authors, such as Isidore de Seville (7th century) and Hugues de Saint-Victor (12nd century), classified the peoples according to their biblical origin, bringing them back to the three sons of Noah: Shem, Ham, and Japheth. These classifications had religious connotations and were used to justify the social and political hierarchies of the time.
- Crusades (11st-13rd centuries) reinforced the distinction between Christians and non-Christians, and contributed to the perception of opposition between peoples of European origin and those of Eastern origin, such as Muslims and Jews (Riley-Smith, 2005, The Crusades: A History)
Renaissance and Modern Age
The notion of race began to take on a more biological dimension from the Renaissance and modern times, with geographical discoveries and the first scientific classifications of human beings. The word "race" comes from the old French "race" or "rase", possibly influenced by the Italian "razza", which are both derived from the Latin "radix", meaning "root". The term "race" was used for the first time to describe distinct human groups on the basis of physical and biological characteristics 16th century. - European explorers 15th century and beyond have met new peoples and cultures, which has led to a more systematic classification of human beings according to their physical and cultural characteristics.1
- Naturalists and anthropologists of the 18th and 19th centuries, such as Carl von Linné (1707-1778) and Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752-1840), began classifying human beings into different "races" based on physical characteristics, such as skin colour, skull shape and other anatomical traits.2 These classifications were based on empirical observations and scientific theories of the time, and laid the foundation for the modern notion of race.
Contemporary period
In the 19th century, Count Arthur de Gobineau, a French diplomat and writer, developed an influential theory on human races. In his major work, "Essai on the inequality of human races" (1853-1855), Gobineau argued that the human races (black, white, yellow) were unequal and that the Aryans, "race of lords" whom he considered superior to the other white ethnic groups, i.e. the European white proletarians, were responsible for the creation of the great civilizations. In the context of a decline in the effectiveness of the religious legitimization of bourgeois supremacy, this legitimation based on biology seduced a good part of the counter-revolutionary bourgeoisie of the nineteenth century, which had to justify its privileges in the face of a proletariat that challenged them as it rose. Gobineau's ideas had a significant influence on subsequent racial and eugenic theories, particularly in Germany, where they contributed to the formation of Nazi ideology. The notion of race continued to evolve after the Second World War, with persistent debates and controversies. Racial bionegationism is based on the idea that genetic and anthropological studies would have shown that differences between human groups are largely superficial and that genetic diversity within groups is often greater than that between groups.3 The notion of race continues to play an important role in discussions on identity, social policies and justice. Researchers and activists promoting the prohibition of the notion of race highlight inequalities and discrimination based on race4 while studying only the social and cultural causes, starting from the obligatory dogma according to which any difference is only the result of an artificial human construction and that it must remain unthinkable to ask whether there could be a biological foundation as small as it is.
Conclusion
The notion of race has traversed history, taking different forms and meanings according to times and cultures. Although the concept of race as we know it today has evolved over the centuries, it is clear that the notion of race existed in various ways in ancient times and in the Middle Ages, in the form of ethnic, cultural and religious distinctions. Understanding the evolution of the notion of race throughout history can help us better understand the current stakes and debates around this complex and controversial concept.
Notes et références
Carte des liens de cette fiche
Continuer