Liste
Critiques and controversies around Wikipedia
The Wikipedia online encyclopedia and its practices have raised numerous criticisms and controversies on various aspects, such as reliability, vulnerability to interest groups, bias, quality of articles and site governance.
Vulnerability to interest groups
Some of the controversies about the influence of businesses, lobbying and particular interest groups on Wikipedia content. Concerns include manipulation of articles by external actors, promotion of political or economic agendas, and compromise of impartiality and neutrality of articles. These problems call into question the independence and objectivity of the information presented on Wikipedia. Access and contribution difficulties for novices New contributors may encounter difficulties in accessing and contributing to Wikipedia, due to the complexity of the site's rules and procedures, as well as the learning curve needed to master the writing and discussion tools.1 Lack of recognition and support for contributors Wikipedia contributors may not receive the recognition and support they deserve for their volunteer work, which may discourage unselfish participation and affect the quality of content. The efforts of contributors may go unnoticed or be underestimated, especially when working on less popular or controversial topics.2 Influence of business and lobbying Companies and lobbyists can influence Wikipedia content to their advantage by modifying articles or funding contributors to promote their interests. This influence can undermine the impartiality and neutrality of the encyclopedia.3 Conflicts of interest and remunerated contributions Conflicts of interest may arise when contributors are paid to modify items, often for the purpose of promoting commercial or political interests. These practices may compromise the impartiality and neutrality of the articles.4
Partial and arbitrary administration of the site
Some of the controversies related to the impartiality and neutrality of articles, power inequalities between contributors, conflicts of interest and remunerated contributions, and opaque and arbitrary decision-making processes. These issues raise concerns about the fairness and transparency of Wikipedia's governance processes. Opaque and arbitrary decision-making process Wikipedia's decision-making processes can be opaque and arbitrary, with decisions made by a small group of administrators without sufficient consultation or participation from the contributor community.5 Inequalities of power between contributors Some Wikipedia contributors have more power and influence than others, particularly because of their status as administrators or seniority. These inequalities can lead to arbitrary decisions and abuse of power.6 Dependence on donations and funding Wikipedia relies heavily on donations and funding to support its infrastructure and operations. This dependence may raise questions about the long-term viability of the encyclopedia and its ability to withstand financial pressures.7 Centralization of power Contrary to popular ideas, power within Wikipedia can be concentrated in the hands of a small group of influential administrators and contributors, which can lead to abuse of power and arbitrary decisions. Centralization can also discourage the participation of new contributors and foster a culture of exclusion.8 Under-representation of women Women are under-represented among Wikipedia contributors, representing about 10 % community. This underrepresentation can lead to bias in content, focusing on male perspectives and neglecting women's contributions in various areas.9 Censorship and deletion of articles Some Wikipedia articles may be censored or deleted for controversial reasons, for example due to political, commercial or ideological pressures. These practices raise concerns about the freedom of expression and the independence of the encyclopedia.10 Governance and site administration Wikipedia management can be criticized for its lack of transparency and accountability. Important decisions are sometimes made by a small group of administrators, without sufficient consultation or involvement of the contributor community.
Intellectual gaps
Some of the controversies related to the quality of articles and sources, awareness biases, editorial control and linguistic and cultural biases. These problems suggest that Wikipedia does not always cover subjects in an exhaustive, balanced and representative manner. Quality of articles and sources The quality of articles and sources used varies considerably on Wikipedia. Some articles are well documented and based on reliable sources, while others may be incomplete, poorly written or supported by unreliable sources.11 Lack of diversity in topics covered Wikipedia may lack diversity in the topics covered, focusing on certain areas of knowledge and neglecting others. This situation can lead to an inequitable and incomplete representation of the wealth of human knowledge.12 Language and Anglophony Wikipedia is often criticized for its bias towards English content. Articles in English are generally more numerous, more detailed and better referenced than articles in other languages, including French, which can create inequalities between the different linguistic communities.13 Impartiality and neutrality of articles Wikipedia articles may have biases due to the subjectivity of contributors or external influences. The neutrality of the articles is often questioned, as dominant or majority views may prevail over alternative perspectives.14
Fail and illegal practices
Some of the controversies related to vandalism, plagiarism, abuse of copyright and security and confidentiality issues on Wikipedia. These problems call into question the integrity of the content and the protection of the rights of authors and users. Online Harassment and Toxic Behaviour Wikipedia contributors can face online harassment and toxic behaviour from other users, which can discourage participation and affect content quality.15 Abuse of copyright Wikipedia can be criticized for copyright violations and misuse of protected content. Certain images, texts or other elements present on the site may be used without permission or without complying with the conditions of licence.16 Plagiarism and violation of intellectual property Cases of plagiarism and infringement of intellectual property have been reported on Wikipedia, particularly with regard to reproduction of texts or images without authorization or without appropriate attribution. These practices can undermine the reputation and credibility of the encyclopedia.17 Security and confidentiality issues Wikipedia may face security and privacy issues, particularly as regards the protection of users' personal data and the prevention of computer attacks. These problems can undermine user confidence and the reputation of the encyclopedia.18
Lack of reliability
Some of the controversies related to the reliability and verifiability of information about Wikipedia, disinformation, as well as problems related to dependence on donations and funding. These questions suggest that Wikipedia may sometimes be a less reliable source of information than other encyclopedias or sources of information. Reliability and verifiability of information Wikipedia articles may contain errors and unverified information, particularly because of the open and collaborative nature of the site. Some experts question the reliability of the encyclopedia because of these problems.19 Vandalism and misinformation Wikipedia may be a victim of vandalism and misinformation, with articles deliberately modified to include false or misleading information. While the community is working to address these problems, they can undermine the reputation and reliability of the encyclopedia.20
Notes et références
- Nov, Oded (2007). "What Motivates Wikipedians?". Communications of the ACM 50 (11): 60-64.↩
- Forte, Andrea; Bruckman, Amy (2005). "Why Do People Write for Wikipedia? Incentives to Contribute to Open-Content Publishing". GROUP '05 Workshop: Sustaining Community.↩
- Orlowski, Andrew (2012). "Wikipedia's Sockpuppet Problem." The Register.↩
- Orlowski, Andrew (2012). "Wikipedia's Sockpuppet Problem." The Register.↩
- Tkacz, Nathaniel (2010). "The Politics of Forking Paths." Critical Point of View: A Wikipedia Reader: 121-131.↩
- Halfaker, Aaron; Geiger, R. Stuart; Morgan, Jonathan T.; Riedl, John (2012). "The Rise and Decline of an Open Collaboration System: How Wikipedia's Reaction to Popularity Is Causing Its Decline". American Behavioral Scientist 57 (5): 664-688.↩
- Rask, M.; Lausen, S.L.; Lomi, A.; Obel, B. (2006). "Wikipedia at the Tipping Point: An Analysis of the Work Process in the English Wikipedia". Proceedings of the 14th European Conference on Information Systems.↩
- Reagle, Joseph Michael (2010). "Do as I Do: Authentic Leadership in Wikipedia". In Critical Point of View: A Wikipedia Reader, edited by Geert Lovink and Nathaniel Tkacz, 259-268. Amsterdam: Institute of Network Cultures.↩
- Hill, Benjamin Mako; Shaw, Aaron (2013). "The Wikipedia Gender Gap Revisited". PLOS ONE 8 (6): e65782.↩
- Emigh, William; Herring, Susan C. (2005). "Collaborative Authoring on the Web: A Genre Analysis of Online Encyclopedias". Proceedings of the Thirty-Eighth Hawaii'i International Conference on System Sciences.↩
- Fallis, Don (2008). "Toward an Epistemology of Wikipedia". Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 59 (10): 1662-1674.↩
- Heilman, James M.; West, Andrew G. (2015). "Wikipedia and Medicine: Quantifying Readership, Editors, and the Significance of Natural Language". Journal of Medical Internet Research 17 (3): e62.↩
- Hecht, Brent; Gergle, Darren (2010). "The Tower of Babel Meets Web 2.0: User-Generated Content and Its Applications in a Multilingual Context". Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems: 291-300.↩
- Finkelstein, Seth (2008). "The Wikipedia FAQK". The Guardian.↩
- Ford, Heather; Wajcman, Judy (2017). "'Anyone can edit', Not Everyone Does: Wikipedia's Infrastructure and the Gender Gap". Social Studies of Science 47 (4): 511-527.↩
- Fiesler, Casey; Bruckman, Amy (2014). "Remixers' Understandings of Fair Use Online". Proceedings of the 17th ACM Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work & Social Computing: 1023-1032.↩
- Chesney, Thomas (2006). "An Empirical Examination of Wikipedia's Credibility". First Monday 11 (11).↩
- West, Andrew G.; Chang, Jian; Venkatasubramanian, Krishna P.; Sokolsky, Oleg (2010). "Trust in Collaborative Web Applications". Future Generation Computer Systems 26 (8): 1068-1080.↩
- Giles, Jim (2005). "Internet encyclopaedias go head to head". Nature 438: 900-901.↩
- Zuckerman, Ethan (2011). "The First Twitter Revolution?" Foreign Policy.↩
Carte des liens de cette fiche
Continuer