Wiki Polyism
Adapter la lectureVersion adaptée active

Christianisme · Concepts

Christian Cacogenism

The christian cacogenism is a Christian ideological doctrine defending the idea that procreation must be accompanied by suffering and risks, also associated with the rejection of any eugenic-liberal mastery of its reproductive functions. This concept is rooted primarily in the teachings and values of Christianity.

Origin

The term "cacogenism" comes from ancient Greek "kakos" (bad) and "genesis" (origin, birth), while "Christian" refers to beliefs and values arising from Christianity.

Theological origins

Christian cacogenism derives its origins from the Bible and the writings of the Church Fathers. In Genesis, God condemns Eve to bring forth in pain after original sin: - (Genesis) 3:16) "To the woman he said: I will increase the pain of your pregnancies, you will bring forth in pain. Your desires will push you to your husband, and he will rule over you."1 Augustine considered that the suffering of childbirth was an inevitable consequence of original sin. - "This is how we were all born of the seed of sin, that our nature, generated by a deregulated passion, could not fail to transmit us." 2

  • "That is why the woman, who had been created to help the man, was subjected to the man by this law of marriage, which imposes on her, in punishment for her sin, the penalty of childbirth and childbirth." 3 Saint Thomas of Aquinas, one of the main Christian theologians, also addresses the question of the pain of childbirth in the Theological Somme: - "The pain of childbirth was not imposed on the woman as a necessary consequence of procreation, but as a punishment of sin. For if man had not sinned, procreation would have been free of pain." 4 This vision of procreation is accompanied by a rejection of eugenics, which is considered an interference in the divine plan. In the encyclical Humanae Vitae (1968Pope Paul VI condemns methods of artificial contraception and stresses the importance of natural reproduction: - "It is forbidden for every man, for any reason, in any form and with any intention whatsoever, to perform any positive act for the purpose of procreation, except in marriage and precisely while respecting God's order for procreation." 5
  • "It is not permitted, even for serious reasons, to resort to means which are contrary to moral law, i.e. which contradict the normal course of the conjugal act and thus prevent procreation." 6
  • "Similarly, one cannot invoke as valid reasons, in order to justify the acts of marriage deliberately rendered infecund, any evil or the fact that such acts would constitute a whole with the previous or future fruitful acts, to form a single and indivisible whole. " 7 In the encyclical "Encyclical Evangelium Vitae" (1995Pope John Paul II criticises eugenics and emphasizes the dignity and sanctity of human life: - "In our time, eugenic temptation takes on new forms, because of the discoveries made in the fields of genetics and molecular biology, as well as in medical care and interventions on the human embryo. In reality, we are establishing a real 'right to the child', to a 'healthy' child, and even to the 'best' child possible." 8

Historical events

Christian cacogenism has influenced various policies and practices throughout history. For example, the Catholic Church's opposition to contraception and abortion can be understood as a manifestation of Christian cacogenism. Similarly, the opposition of some Christian communities to genetic research and medically assisted reproductive techniques also stems from this concept.

Criticisms and debates

Christian cacogenism has been criticized for its potentially negative impact on public health and the well-being of individuals, especially women. Some argue that this vision of reproductive health perpetuates unnecessary suffering and limits access to reproductive health care. Other criticisms relate to the incompatibility of Christian cacogenism with modern scientific and medical advances.

Notes et références

  1. The Bible, Genesis 3:16↩
  2. Saint Augustine. (397-400). Confessions, Book I, Chapter 7.↩
  3. Saint Augustine. (413-426). The City of God, Book XXII, Chapter 22.↩
  4. Saint Thomas of Aquinas. (1265-1274). Theological sum, I-II, Question 98Article 2.↩
  5. Paul VI1968). Humanae Vitae, No 11.↩
  6. Paul VI1968). Humanae Vitae, No 14.↩
  7. Paul VI1968). Humanae Vitae, No 14.↩
  8. John Paul II. (1995). Encyclical Evangelium Vitae, No 63.↩